If you are specifying or sourcing lighting for a project, you have likely come across the question: what is a downlight? A downlight, sometimes called a spotlight or recessed light, is a fitting installed into the ceiling so that the body of the light is concealed, with only the front face visible in the room. They can be fixed or adjustable, fire rated or standard, and IP rated for use in bathrooms and wet areas. They are one of the most popular lighting choices in residential projects and renovations.
Due to their popularity, downlights are readily available through a wide number of manufacturers and suppliers. Inevitably, some will be better quality and deliver better results than others.There is a huge difference between the low and high ends of the market. Due to the competitive nature of project tendering, often price is the only deciding factor, and the client will not realise a bad choice has been made until it is too late.
Below are the key attributes which form the basis for a good fitting. Considering these will help you to choose the right downlight for your project.
Colour Consistency
The manufacturing process of an LED is not perfectly precise, so a variety of different whites is produced. These are then split into groups called bins. A good quality downlight will use LEDs from one to two bins to ensure colour matching, while poor quality fittings will use a variety of different bins to reduce the price. This results in slightly different colours across the ceiling.
A good way to identify well matched LEDs is to look at the MacAdam Ellipse rating. A 2-step MacAdam Ellipse is good, while a 4-step is going to have some variation.
Colour Rendering
We have all experienced trying on clothes in a shop, thinking they are one colour, and then getting outside and finding they look completely different. Colour rendering is a measure of how accurately colours are seen under a light source. A good quality downlight will have a Colour Rendering Index (CRI) of 90 or above. Standard downlights will have an 80+ rating, but these tend to render red and warm tones poorly. Poor colour rendering means the subject of the light will look washed out and drab.
Dimming
When choosing a good quality downlight, it will be compatible with most dimmers and will provide detailed information on what they require. Good quality downlights will also dim to very low levels, with a good target being 0.1%. A 1 to 5% level is reasonable. A poor-quality downlight will only go as low as 30%, which is not low enough to be used practically. Furthermore, good quality downlights will not flicker and will stay on even when dimmed to very low levels. Compare this to a lower quality downlight, which will have a point where it flickers or strobes, although this can also be the result of a poor-quality dimmer.
For more information on this topic, read about the different ways of dimming LED lights.
Glare Control
Glare happens when the actual light source is visible. It can be extremely irritating and distracting. A good quality downlight will have some form of glare control, such as a baffle. This means the actual LED light source will not be visible when seen from within the room, and this helps create a softer light. Low quality downlights will have far too much glare, which can ruin the atmosphere of a room and cause issues such as headaches.
Light Output
Light output can vary greatly from one downlight to another. For residential use, a downlight should have a light output of 500 lumens or above, but some poorer quality options which are stated as being for standard use actually only deliver around 300 lumens.
Energy Efficiency
Quality and energy efficiency tend to go together in the downlight market. LEDs sold today average close to 100 lumens per watt, with premium professional models exceeding 200 lm/W, compared to around 20 lm/W for a traditional halogen lamp. In practical terms, at the current UK average electricity rate of around 24p per kWh, replacing ten 50W halogen spotlights with 5W LED equivalents running for five hours a day saves approximately £98 a year. A good quality downlight will also carry a clear energy label and provide transparent efficacy data, making it easier to assess value over the lifetime of the fitting.
Beam Angles
Having a variety of beam angles available for a project is extremely useful. Ideally, you would want narrow, medium, wide, and flood options, as this gives flexibility in how they are used within a space. Many standard, lower-quality downlights only offer one beam angle of 45 to 60 degrees, which will not be suitable for many spaces.
Read our article on beam angles for more detail.
Adjustability
One optional feature that will not be included on standard downlights is the ability to tilt and rotate the fitting, allowing the light to be directed once it is installed. This can be a useful feature for accent lighting or highlighting specific areas of a room.
Aesthetics
A good quality downlight will minimise its visibility within the space, either by having a plastered-in frame or small trims. A lower quality downlight could potentially look obtrusive and unsightly.
Fire Rating
Having the option of a fire rated fitting will be beneficial as it simplifies the installation process and ensures compliance with building regulations where required. This will only be available on better quality downlights.
Our guide to fire rating fittings provides further advice on this.
IP Rating
When choosing lighting for bathrooms, showers and external use, a specific IP rating is required. Having the option of an IP rated version of a downlight can be very helpful to maintain consistency throughout a project, so it is important to check the IP rating of a fitting before you buy.
Our guide to IP ratings offers a detailed look at this.
Modularity And Repair
A good quality downlight will be able to be broken down into separate components including the LED module, the body, the driver, and other elements. This means that if these individual components fail, they can potentially be repaired or replaced independently. Lower quality downlights contain everything in one unit with no separate pieces. When one part fails, the whole fitting will need to be replaced. This can be particularly problematic if exactly the same model is no longer available, making it impossible to match the other fittings used in the space.
Recycling
As mentioned above, a good downlight will be modular, and therefore easy to take apart to allow individual components to be recycled. A manufacturer might also provide a service to refurbish or repair fittings, or even a buyback scheme. As lower quality fittings cannot be disassembled for recycling, the whole unit ends up in landfill.
Ease Of Installation
A well-designed fitting will make it easier for the contractor to install the downlight, as well as removing it if it needs to be repaired in the future. Poorer quality fittings will be complicated to install, or will not include adequate guidance, resulting in delays on site and potentially broken fittings that then need replacing.
Speak To Our Team
There is clearly a lot to consider when choosing a quality downlight. Understanding what is a downlight and what separates a good one from a poor one is the starting point for getting the right result on any project. If you would like some help or advice, please get in touch with our team on 020 7112 4901 or email us at info@emberlighting.co.uk.